Melt Bar + Grilled
Mac & Cheese Bites – Batter, Fried with Cheddar Cheese Sauce and Parmesan
Half-Chorizo and Potato – Fresh Ground Spicy Sausage and Hearty Potato Hash, Sharp Cheddar + an Egg
Half-The Dude Abides – Homemade Meatballs, Fried Mozzarella Wedges, Basil Marinara, Roasted Garlic, Provolone, Romano
Half-Cuban War Pig – Honey Ham, Mojo Glazed Pulled Pork, Fried Pickle Spears, Honey Mustard, Swiss
Half-Monte Cristo – Honey Ham, Smoked Turkey, Swiss, American, Crispy Battered and Deep Fried with Powdered Sugar and Berry Preserves
Voodoo Zombie Jerk Chicken Melt – Roasted Pulled Jerk Chicken, Fried and Smashed Plantains, Caribbean Pickled Peppers and Onions, Peach Habanero Marmalade, Pepper-Jack Cheese with Zombie Dust Seasoning
Half-Peanut Butter & Banana – Caramelized Banana, House Made Peanut Butter, Sweet Cream Cheese, Candied Peanuts, Berry Preserves
Peanut Butter Halloween Candy Bread Pudding – Homemade Chocolate Candy Bread, Rich Peanut Butter Frosting, Peanut Butter Glaze, Vanilla Ice Cream, Whipped Cream, Powdered Sugar
At this point probably the most famous Cleveland eatery outside those owned by Michael Symon, it was prior to expansion that I paid my one and only visit to Melt Bar + Grilled, a long day of Roller Coasters with family leaving all of us famished and thus in a perfect state to re-visit owner Matt Fish’s Grilled Cheese concept in its latest and greatest format, the Independence location at least quadrupling the original’s tiny floor plan.
Now sporting some half-dozen restaurants, all thriving including those in Akron and Columbus, it was just past 9:00pm that our party of three was offered seating amidst televisions and luminescent plastic lawn ornaments, a middle-aged server with the company since nearly day one explaining a few daily specials before leaving us to our decisions, the recent addition of half-sandwiches allowing a whole lot of variety including appetizers and dessert.
Showing Sunday night football in below a soundtrack of tunes spanning the sixties through the eighties it was with still more people entering to fill our section that items started arriving, three golden Mac & Cheese Bites followed by two more with a joke about the cook’s math skills, the gooey insides somehow still featuring springy Pasta with extra Cheese sauce added for dipping.
Unable go halfsies on specials, the Voodoo Zombie Chicken Melt thus arriving in whole and flanked by a quartet of half-Sandwiches, those looking for a bit of heat will be happy to know that the Halloween themed dish packed plenty without going atomic or tongue-melting by way of Pickled Peppers and Plantains, the housemade Chorizo actually a bit more poignant as the breakfast favorite was topped iun crispy Potato Hash and an add-on soft-poached Egg.
Spinning the classic Meatball Sub forward with fried Mozzarella triangles, the Big Lebowski themed title not particularly sensible unless there is a subtle Italian reference in the film that I missed, more great bites were found amongst the messy Cuban War-Pig that sees Havana’s famous Sandwich re-created with Frickles and Honey Mustard, the fried Monte Cristo going all-in with both Ham and Turkey plus Swiss and Raspberry Preserves, a rarely seen combination that some will say is true to the dish’s earliest diner origins.
Not particularly interested in Fried Twinkies, another Half-Sandwich joining the Seasonal Bread Pudding to round out our meal, my only regret was not ordering the Peanut Butter & Banana Sandwich with a trip to the deep-fryer, the results still tasty but lacking in the face of Custard soaked Chocolate Bread wrapped around Peanut Butter Frosting atop a bed of housemade Whipped Cream and crowned with an oversized scoop of Vanilla Ice Cream.

